home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1741>
- <title>
- Dec. 12, 1994: Show Business:I Like New York in Yule
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Dec. 12, 1994 To the Dogs
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- THE ARTS & MEDIA/SHOW BUSINESS, Page 82
- I Like New York in Yule
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> With Rockettes, stores and Scrooges, Manhattan evokes the ghosts
- of Christmas past
- </p>
- <p>By Richard Corliss--Reported by Elizabeth L. Bland and William Tynan/New York
- </p>
- <p> Why is New York the most hated city in America? Partly because
- it is so very old, with all the ailments that attend decrepitude.
- The town is seen as a doddering, muttering, pest-ridden bag
- lady. New York can hardly remember the glory days when it was
- an empress, exquisite in its elegance and clout. In that gilded
- time, Manhattan was also the world's show-biz Mecca, a glamour
- magnet of theater, department stores and cafe society. Today
- those species are endangered or extinct.
- </p>
- <p> Once a year, though, like a princess who has been sleeping in
- rags, the town stirs itself to recall its grand traditions.The
- grimace crinkles into a smile, the Grinch is transformed into
- Santa Claus--and the rest of the country pays homage. For
- New York is Christmas Central. Manhattan owns this glitziest
- and most sentimental of seasons, beginning with Macy's Thanksgiving
- Day parade and culminating in Times Square on New Year's Eve.
- </p>
- <p> Outsiders want in; they fill midtown's hotels and clot its traffic.
- Secular pilgrims, they trek to the Christmas tree in Rockefeller
- Center (and to its sibs at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in
- Trump Tower and at Lincoln Center). They see a holiday show:
- the Radio City Christmas Spectacular, which will attract a million
- patrons this year at $25 to $55 a ticket, or another family
- entertainment (the Big Apple Circus, Shari Lewis' Lamb Chop
- on Broadway). And they window-shop on Fifth Avenue--a promenade
- that remains the city's most bustling theatrical experience.
- </p>
- <p> In its totality, the visit is a time trip to a prettier New
- York and a sweeter America. "When I was little, I used to come
- with my grandmother," says Nancy Murray of Scotch Plains, New
- Jersey, of her annual trip to Radio City. "I loved it; the show
- always gave me the Christmas spirit. It still does. And when
- my son is old enough, I hope he will come with his grandmother."
- </p>
- <p> Every large city ties itself in a big red bow each Christmas,
- but no place gets with the holiday program in quite the way
- New York does. Across from the Rockefeller Center tree, Saks
- Fifth Avenue tells the Yuletide tale of plucky Art Aimesworth
- vs. the Dark Elves in six sprightly windows (with narration
- by Cindy Crawford, Peter Duchin, Brooke Shields, Dominick Dunne,
- Martha Stewart and seven others). At Fendi the Christmas trees
- are as svelte and haughty as the Euro-mannequins. From the windows
- of the Warner Bros. Studio Store, a behemoth Bugs and three
- of his Looney Tunes pals gaze fretfully across 57th Street at
- the Tiffany's display--cuddly bears in tuxedos, snow gear
- and seraphim wings.
- </p>
- <p> Virtually the only Fifth Avenue building without even a sprig
- of festoonery is Saint Patrick's Cathedral. But then Christmas
- in New York, as in most American cities, is less a religious
- feast than a mercantile festival, whose motto could be "Buy
- now, pray later." Many retailers rely on this season for fully
- half their sales and profits. Similarly, performing-arts organizations
- use holiday chestnuts like Amahl and the Night Visitors and
- Handel's Messiah as surefire crowd lures. The New York City
- Ballet's production of George Balanchine's The Nutcracker plays
- to more than 100,000 people each Christmas and earns the company
- a fat $5.6 million. For regional theaters, A Christmas Carol
- is an even bigger cash cow. "It pays the bills for the rest
- of the season," says Lawrence Harbison of Samuel French Inc.,
- the premier play-licensing house. The adaptation of Dickens'
- 1843 cautionary classic is by far the most widely produced play
- on the regional circuit.
- </p>
- <p> It is also, this month, a Broadway-style quadruple whammy. This
- week brings A Tuna Christmas (a sequel to the long-running Texas
- jape Greater Tuna), featuring a disaster-prone production of
- the Dickens story. In two weeks Patrick Stewart shucks his Star
- Trek: Generations uniform for the dark garb of Ebenezer Scrooge
- to give 21 dramatic readings of A Christmas Carol. This is Stewart's
- third New York Christmas in four years, and each time his show
- has sold out, leading to successively larger venues. This year
- he will fill the 1,400-seat Richard Rodgers Theatre at $40 and
- $50 a ticket. Thus does Captain Picard of the 24th century reach
- back to the 19th--for one man who made a profitable career
- of reading A Christmas Carol onstage, in both England and the
- U.S., was Dickens himself.
- </p>
- <p> It has been said that with that little book, Dickens invented
- Christmas--the holiday as we know it, with lavish presents
- and greeting cards, with liberal sentiment and family gatherings,
- and with the spirit of generosity helping to stanch the guilty
- suspicion that we hadn't been charitable enough on the other
- 364 days. Shopkeepers and toymakers can thank Dickens; put-upon
- parents can blame him, though the commercial excesses perpetrated
- in the name of Christmas were the last thing this radical social
- reformer had in mind.
- </p>
- <p> A little of Dickens' furious humanism surfaces in the most lavish
- Christmas Carol on display this month in New York. This is the
- $12 million musical version playing at Madison Square Garden's
- Paramount theater with its 5,200 seats. The huge stage is dense
- with the crippled, the homeless, the starving--and, in this
- morass of need, one man, Scrooge (Walter Charles), railing against
- those who would help them. "Are there no prisons? Are there
- no workhouses?" Add an "Are there no orphanages?" and you have
- the agenda of the next Speaker of the House.
- </p>
- <p> As it happens, one model for this Scrooge was not Newt Gingrich
- but Charles Dickens. "He was a very generous man," says Mike
- Ockrent, the show's director and co-author, "but I think he
- viewed himself as a potential Scrooge--what he might have
- become had his attitude been different." This Christmas Carol
- grafts part of Dickens' biography (his days as a child laborer,
- his father's trip to debtors' prison) onto Scrooge. It makes
- him less a villain than a victim of his times. "Scrooge is really
- every one of us," notes the show's composer, Alan Menken. "We
- all have a tendency to watch out for our interests and to avoid
- taking responsibility for the fate of the world."
- </p>
- <p> The more obvious message of the new Carol is that it's big and
- pretty--holiday candy for the whole family at $19 to $55 a
- ticket. It was confected by Broadway's top talent, including
- set designer Tony Walton, costume designer William Ivey Long,
- choreographer Susan Stroman and lyricist Lynn Ahrens. Some are
- working at half speed. Menken's melodies are less inventive
- than his scores for the Disney cartoons The Little Mermaid and
- Beauty and the Beast. He gets a B+ for hummable ballads and
- ho-humbuggable comic turns. Stroman's jazziest ideas are reprises
- of her dancing-on-furniture number from Crazy for You. Ahrens'
- lyrics are wan, snapless. It takes a while for the 90-min. show
- to become more than the sum of its parts.
- </p>
- <p> But what parts! Walton attached rows of Victorian houses to
- both ends of the Paramount stage (already double the width of
- the standard Broadway stage) so that it seems to embrace the
- audience. And everywhere there is wonder to behold: Jacob Marley's
- huge skull glowering on the facade of Scrooge's house, sets
- that open and fold like mammoth pop-up Christmas cards, a spider
- web of gold chains on which Scrooge is crucified by remorseful
- ghosts, a tombstone that forces him into the rising fires of
- hell.
- </p>
- <p> Ockrent loved the Christmas pantomimes of his English youth,
- with their gaudy costumes and giddy parody. "We have to introduce
- kids to the theater," he says, "so their imaginations are stimulated
- intellectually and visually." In his Christmas Carol, children
- will find plenty to keep them beguiled: high-stepping oranges
- and pears, the flight of Scrooge and the Ghost of Christmas
- Future above the audience, a bountiful snowfall on the expensive
- seats and, at the end, Christmas trinkets distributed by the
- cast to lucky theatergoers.
- </p>
- <p> The show is playing 85 times through Jan. 1, with as many as
- four shows a day. Even so, with a cast of 90 and devilishly
- elaborate special effects, this very Menken Christmas Carol
- won't break even for a few years. The producers hope to make
- it a holiday tradition in New York and other cities. "It's a
- story that has lasted 150 years," says Ockrent, "and I don't
- see why it shouldn't last another 150. Hopefully at the Paramount."
- </p>
- <p> Well, he could hope that A Christmas Carol lasts as long as
- the Radio City holiday show, which has been going since 1933
- and never looked better. Under the direction of Robert Longbottom
- (Pageant), the show struts the ageless panache of the 36 Rockettes
- in five precision prances, notably as a parade of wooden soldiers
- and as Raggedy Anns whose letter blocks eventually spell out
- merry christmas and a happy new year. A new version of The Nutcracker,
- with teddy bear dancers as sugar plum fairies, Arabian houris
- and Chinese pandas, is delicate, funny, winning. The climactic
- Nativity tableau--teeming with camels, sheep, donkeys and
- some robust piety--is bold enough to remind the audience who
- the real star of Christmas is. And, yes, there's a brisk, fanciful
- version of the Scrooge story--in 12 minutes!
- </p>
- <p> In its finesse and sweep, the Radio City spectacle summons up
- more than the best spirit of Christmas past. It creates a vision
- of old New York, when any young couple could think themselves
- as suave as Fred and Ginger on the ballroom floor or two skaters
- in love on the Rockefeller Center ice rink. Perhaps this image
- is no closer to reality than the current dark dream of Manhattan
- as Hell on the Hudson, but it tickles the mind nonetheless.
- Emerging from the show, locals and visitors alike can think,
- for a New York minute, that this is the capital of Christmas.
-
- </p></body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-